Vision and Mission - What's the difference and why does it matter?
In a previous blog, I provided an overview of strategic planning processes, including six core elements essential to any successful strategic plan.
The six core elements are as follows:
Strategic Areas of Focus
For over 18 years, I have facilitated strategic planning initiatives with many diverse organizations. From my experience, I believe there is a lot of confusion regarding the difference between a Vision and Mission statement.
Why does it matter if there is confusion about Vision and Mission statements, or if they are written in a certain way?
For the same reasons it is fundamental and valuable for any organization to have a strategic plan as a road map for success, it is important to develop a plan around a clearly defined and well written Vision and Mission.
Both serve important, yet different roles as core elements of a strategic plan.
- Attracting/engaging/retaining talent;
- Building organizational culture; and,
- Increasing productivity while leveraging all resources to successfully implement a strategic plan.
In this blog, I will explain the difference between a Vision and Mission statement from an organizational development perspective, include real world examples, and expand on the benefits they bring to an organization.
What is a Vision Statement?
A Vision Statement:
- Defines the optimal desired future state - the mental picture - of what an organization wants to achieve over time;
- Provides guidance and inspiration as to what an organization is focused on achieving in five, ten, or more years;
- Functions as the "north star" - it is what all employees understand their work every day ultimately contributes towards accomplishing over the long term; and,
- Is written succinctly in an inspirational manner that makes it easy for all employees to repeat it at any given time.
Defining an organization's Vision is not always easy for senior leadership to do. James M. Kouzes and Barry Z. Posner wrote an article about this challenge for Harvard Business Review, "To Lead, Create a Shared Vision."
Kouzes and Posner, also creators of "The Leadership Practices Inventory," analyzed responses from over one million leaders about this. The data indicated that one of the things leaders struggle with the most is "communicating an image of the future that draws others in - that speaks to what others see and feel." Kouzes and Posner's research also indicated that "being forward-looking - envisioning exciting possibilities and enlisting others in a shared view of the future - is the attribute that most distinguishes leaders from non-leaders."
Examples of effective Vision statements include:
Alzheimer's Association: "Our Vision is a world without Alzheimer's disease."
Avon: "To be the company that best understands and satisfies the product, service and self-fulfillment needs of women - globally."
Norfolk Southern: "Be the safest, most customer-focused and successful transportation company in the world."
Microsoft: "Empower people through great software anytime, anyplace, and on any device."
Reston Association: "Leading the model community where all can live, work, and play."
What is a Mission Statement?
A Mission statement:
- Defines the present state or purpose of an organization;
- Answers three questions about why an organization exists -
WHO it does it for; and
HOW it does what it does.
- Is written succinctly in the form of a sentence or two, but for a shorter timeframe (one to three years) than a Vision statement; and,
- Is something that all employees should be able to articulate upon request.
For example, some companies are launched to provide specific products or services; yet, they may realize that changing WHAT they do, or WHO they do it for, or HOW they do what they do, will enable them to grow the business faster and more successfully.
Understanding the Mission gives employees a better perspective on how their job contributes to achieving it, which can increase engagement, retention, and productivity.
Having a clearly defined Mission statement also helps employees better understand things like company-wide decisions, organizational changes, and resource allocation, thereby lessening resistance and workplace conflicts.
Examples of effective Mission statements include:
Erie Insurance: "To provide our policyholders with as near perfect protection, as near perfect service as is humanly possible and to do so at the lowest possible cost."
NatureAir: "To offer travelers a reliable, innovative and fun airline to travel in Central America."
Nissan: "Nissan provides unique and innovative automotive products and services that deliver superior, measurable values to all stakeholders in alliance with Renault."
St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company: "To lead the Canadian specialty commercial insurance industry through innovation, expertise and by providing products and services to satisfy the needs and exceed the expectations of our customers and business partners.
Target: "Our mission is to make Target the preferred shopping destination for our guests by delivering outstanding value, continuous innovation and an exceptional guest experience by consistently fulfilling our Expect More. Pay Less.® brand promise."
If there is no downside to having a clear Vision and Mission, why do some organizations not have them, or have poorly written ones on their websites, lobby walls, brochures, etc.?
Some of the reasons I've heard are:
- "It takes too much time to develop them."
- "We will never reach consensus."
- "Our CEO wrote our Vision, which we know is more like a Mission statement with our values mixed in, but no one is going to question it."
- "Everyone that works here already knows what we do, so what is the benefit of writing a statement about it?
- "We have our goals - who needs a Vision or Mission?
- "It's expensive to take people away from their real job to focus on it."
- "Actually defining our Vision and Mission will mean changes in the organization - who has time to deal with more resistance to change?"
Not having a clearly defined Vision and Mission limits opportunities for the organization's success, and is a disservice to employees who show up for work every day. If an organization wants engaged and productive employees, it should make sure that they know how their work contributes to accomplishing the Mission (current state) and ultimately to the Vision (future state).
In addition to other benefits already mentioned, a clear Vision and Mission statement can:
Vision and Mission - What's the difference and why does it matter? | Psychology Today